Skip to content
NewsPipe

Barnum as a Young Lover

A cheeky, previously unpublished anecdote about a young P. T. Barnum's clandestine courtship — and the friend who sabotaged his midnight exit with disastrous, cistern-shaped results.

NewsPipe summary

Burlington Weekly Free Press · February 11, 1876 · Page 1

2 min read

That was in his big book P. T. Barnum wrote about himself. It is very complete, too, but there is one little incident which he either forgot to mention, or which got pied when the forms went to press. It occurred when the great showman was a young man, and a resident of this section. He was paying impetuous attention to a young lady living in Newton. Being a son of poor but honest parents, he was obliged to walk over to the village which contained his adored, on the Sunday nights he visited her. When there he labored under another and more awkward disadvantage. The young lady's father conceived a singular and most violent dislike of the amiable embryo showman. This necessitated extreme caution on the part of the lover, and he was equal to the emergency, as a matter of course. His ingress to the house was by a window on the second floor, which he reached by springing from the cover of a cistern curb, and catching hold of the window ledge. His egress was effected by hanging full length from the ledge and then dropping to the cistern cover, a fall of about six inches. One Sunday he took with him on the visit a young man who now carries his silvered hairs behind a Danbury grocery counter. They reached the place, the young lady saw the signal, opened the window and the famous Barnum sprung up into bliss. The young man was to amuse himself about the village until the hour of departure. He amused himself. It don't seem possible that any one could be so brutal, but that young man actually removed the cover of the cistern. Then he sat down by the fence and ate currants, and calmly waited for the result. P. T. finished his sparking, and backed out of the window the full length his hands would permit.

"Good-bye," he gasped in a whisper, as he prepared to drop.

"Good-bye, Phinny," she whispered back.

Then he let go, and instantly shot from sight into a yawning abyss of darkness and rain water, and if he had been of solid iron heated to a white glow, he could not have created more of a commotion in striking the water. It is not necessary to repeat what Mr. Barnum said, both when crawling out of the cistern and during the eight miles walk home, but shortly after he became a Universalist. — Danbury News.

Was this worth reading?

This is how the site learns what to look for. Ratings move the weights behind the front page; notes go into the editorial brief that guides what gets pulled from the archives next.

Feedback on “Barnum as a Young Lover”

Elsewhere in the archive

On the New Bustle

Burlington Weekly Free Press · February 11, 1876

A single sharp-tongued sentence of church-porch gossip about fashion and vanity, preserved here as a tiny slice of period wit.

The Ruling Passion Strong in Death

Burlington Weekly Free Press · February 11, 1876 · St. Louis, Missouri

A wry, gently mocking deathbed anecdote from the St. Louis Republican, in which a dying old woman's last words concern nothing more than a disliked hairpiece — a small comic gem about vanity outlasting even life itself.

The Chicago Rothschild

Burlington Weekly Free Press · February 11, 1876 · Detroit, Michigan

A comic tale from the Detroit Free Press about a boastful stranger who claims to be a millionaire when a hotel clerk asks him to pay in advance — a slice of vintage American tall-tale humor, cut short where the original page ends.

A Remarkable Lynching Scene in West Virginia

Burlington Weekly Free Press · February 11, 1876 · Barboursville, West Virginia

A harrowing eyewitness account of a lynching in Barboursville, West Virginia, where a mob hanged a man and nearly hanged a woman for the axe murder of her husband, complete with confessions, prayers, and a near-riot over whether to spare her life.